Sep 05, 2016 even if you do have a reading guide, these questions will still help engage your book club members and provide great conversation starters. The film stars gary oldman, asa butterfield, britt robertson, and carla gugino, and follows a teenage boy, born on mars, who travels to earth principal photography began on september 14, 2015, in albuquerque. The space between us is a musing on the bond between two modernday bombay women. This is a story intimately and compassionately told against the sensuous background of everyday life in bombay. On page 7, samantha asks nellie one of the defining questions of the novel. The space between us brings the connection between geography, psychology, and politics to life. This is a story intimately and compassionately toldagainst the sensuous background of everyday life in bombay. Dec 31, 2005 the space between us is a musing on the bond between two modernday bombay women. The space between us by thrity umrigar overdrive rakuten. Previous post the secrets between us book club discussion questions. The description of the event, october book discussion. Its because of this question which the space between us doesnt answer that the book ends up having an uncomfortably altright sort of undertone. Tehmina becomes the architect of her own life in a way that suggests worlds can intersect and inform one another in a way that enhances each.
The space between us, is available only to members. Thrity umrigar sequel offers another immersive trip. What do you think is the significance of vanessas new. I just watched the space between us and it feels like a movie thats a victim of multiple writers doing multiple rewrites and losing the heart of the film in the process. I just watched the space between us and it feels like a movie.
Alternatively told through the eyes of sera, a parsi widow whose pregnant daughter and soninlaw share her elegant home, and bhima, the elderly housekeeper who must support her orphaned. We announce the book selection on the first monday of the month and discuss on the last monday of the month at. Theres something exhilarating about writing a book. I want everyone to experience the depth and beauty of the authors writing, the power of which moved me to tears on several occasions.
The piece of info we enjoyed learning about was the author wrote the first and last lines of the book. I like to mix some of these generic questions in to our discussion along with more book specific ones, to create a nice balance in the conversation. At what point did you start to think that sam might be right, and richard might actually be too good to be true. The pair experience similar situations in their lives. Bhimais living at the bottom of the indian caste system. Thrity umrigars eighth novel follows the main character of her bestselling the space between us 2006, the servant bhima, over the course of a year. The author has said that although the plot of the space between us is a work of fiction, the character of bhima is based on a woman who used to work in her home when the writer was a teenager. The space between us a portrayal of two women discovering an emotional rapport as they struggle against the confines of a rigid caste system, umrigars captivating second novel echoes the timeless intensity of zora neale hurstons their eyes were watching god, betty smiths a tree grows in.
The lives of these two likable women have parallel experiences that connect them, but there is always that space between them due to class differences. Does anyone know what path this script took to screen. Set in modernday india, it is the story of two compelling and achingly real women. Its a mystifying and fascinating process, a creative elan that galvanizes the writer and makes of the task more enjoyment than effort. Their union is tested again and again, frayed by bhimas servile role, by seras educated, middleclass parsi upbringing, and by the deeplysown seeds of bigotry and class prejudice that rank bhima as less than human.
How does the distance between us contribute to the narratives of immigration into the u. Sera dubash, an uppermiddleclass parsi housewife whose opulent surroundings hide the shame and disappointment of her abusive. Set in modernday india and witnessed through two compelling and achingly real women, the novel shows how the lives of the rich and the poor are intrinsically connected yet vastly removed from each other, and vividly captures how the bonds of. We meet in a private facebook group and chat about a new book every month. Sera dubash, an uppermiddleclass parsi housewife whose opulent surroundings hide the shame and disappointment of her abusive marriage, and bhima, a stoic illiterate hardened by a life of despair and loss, who has worked in the dubash household for more than twenty years. It isnt the words we speak that make us who we are.
Want to see these questions in action, and join a fun monthly online book club no awkward silences, promise. The space between us by thrity umrigar book club discussion. The space between us is a novel about the relationship between two indian women, the uppermiddle class serabai, and her lower class servant, bhima. Space books and science fiction put the depths of space in the palm of your hand. The first human born on mars travels to earth for the first time, experiencing the wonders of the planet through fresh eyes. His new book, the space between us, dives deep into how the places we live influence our politics. The space between us, thrity umrigars poignant novel about a wealthy woman and her downtrodden servant, offers a revealing look at class and gender roles in modern day bombay. Bhima, the unforgettable main character of thrity umrigars beloved national bestseller the space between us, returns in this triumphant sequela poignant and compelling novel in which the former servant struggles against the circumstances of class and misfortune to forge a new path for herself and her granddaughter in modern india. Typically, people who live in crowded cities have smaller personal space preferences than those who live in wideopen spaces. Her husband has left her, taking her son with him, and she has never seen either of them again. May 03, 2011 poignant, evocative, and unforgettable, the space between us is an intimate portrait of a distant yet familiar world. The weight of bhimas tragic past and her intractable present finds its counterbalance in the most unlikely of characters. The space between us, thrity umrigars new novel, is set in bombay, where mistress and servant, sera and bhima, are best friends separated by class, money, religion, geography, and politics. The space between us is a very fitting title to the story of two women in bombay sera, a parsi from the upperclass and her domestic helper bhima, who lives in the slum only 15 minutes away.
Discussion points for the distance between us writers. In sera dubashs home, bhima scrubs the floors of a house in which she remains an outsider. Space books latest scifi and science author interviews. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Keep a comfortable distance and respect personal space. I may be biased, but moms book nook is the best online moms book club youll find. Its not a book that is designed to make readers happy, but the story has a lot to teach us about the unflagging spirits of women determined to make a.
I hadnt read the space between before, but it is now my favourite don aker book. In that book, umrigar had chronicled the friendship between a rich, privileged housewife named sera and her maid, bhima. Nor is the book as descriptively sumptuous as umrigars the space between us. I talked to enos about his new book and the spatial forces that shape social and political life. Set in modernday india and witnessed through two compelling and achingly real women, the novel shows how the lives of the rich and the poor are intrinsically connected yet vastly. The film stars gary oldman, asa butterfield, britt robertson, and carla gugino, and follows a teenage boy, born on mars, who travels to earth. Parvati, an elderly homeless woman who is haunted by a history of her own. The comfortable space between you and someone you know well will probably be much smaller than it would be if you barely knew the other person. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the space between us. Set in modernday india, the space between us is the story of two compelling and achingly real women.
Buy the space between us new ed by umrigar, thrity isbn. Please be aware that this discussion guide may contain spoilers. Dec 12, 2017 his new book, the space between us, dives deep into how the places we live influence our politics. He embarks on an adventure with a streetsmart girl to discover how he came to be. The lives of these two likable women have parallel experiences that connect them, but there is.
I just watched the space between us and it feels like a. In the classic upstairsdownstairs story, you always have a sneaking suspicion that downstairs. The space between us is the second novel by thrity umrigar, published by william morrow and company in january 2006. With gary oldman, asa butterfield, carla gugino, britt robertson. The same holds true for her latest effort, the secrets between us, which is a sequel to 2006s the space between us. Each morning, bhima, a domestic servant in contemporary bombay, leaves her own small shanty in the slums to tend to another womans house. The space between by don aker amys marathon of books.
By going into the neighborhoods of real cities, enos shows how our perceptions of racial, ethnic, and religious groups are intuitively shaped by where these groups live and interact daily. Introduction poignant and compelling, evocative and unforgettable, the space between us is an intimate portrait of a distant yet familiar world. Poignant, evocative, and unforgettable, the space between us is an intimate portrait of a distant yet familiar world. Book description poignant, evocative, and unforgettable, the space between us is an intimate portrait of a distant yet familiar world. Reading guide for the space between us by thrity umrigar. Jan 10, 2006 the space between us is a novel about the relationship between two indian women, the uppermiddle class serabai, and her lower class servant, bhima. Erika did a great job giving us background on the author. Sera dubash, an uppermiddleclass parsi housewife and bhima, a stoic illiterate who has worked in the dubash household for more than twenty years. Plot summary the film starts with a press conference with a group of astronauts about to embark on a journey to colonise mars.
The space between us plot summary english movie news. Sera dubash, an uppermiddleclass parsi housewife whose opulent surroundings hide the shame and disappointment of her abusive marriage, and bhima, a stoic illiterate hardened by a life of. Thrity umrigar booklist thrity umrigar message board. Still, its meditation on the complex process of building a new life balances these limitations out. The space between us is a 2017 american romantic science fiction film directed by peter chelsom and written by allan loeb, from a story by stewart schill, richard barton lewis, and loeb. Its an enticing prospect to revisit characters who feel like real acquaintances and settings that. Enos provides lots of evidence about why proximity between racial groups induces conflict a staple of altright thinking but little evidence that desegregation could be used to reverse the. Jun 30, 2018 its because of this question which the space between us doesnt answer that the book ends up having an uncomfortably altright sort of undertone. The space between us by lgratsch see profile 040717.
The space between us thrity umrigar, 2006 harpercollins 352 pp. The bonds of respect, support and companionship between the two women from very different classes and. The secrets between us is a powerful, urgent novel that wields issues of gender and class like a blade. Serabai dubash, an uppermiddleclass widow, and her domestic servant, bhima.
653 2 1314 49 1242 92 741 988 802 138 1270 409 1291 347 345 1239 350 1426 37 442 1267 1369 279 664 1224 1053 266 1127 1267 303 1071 945 745 298 875 703 1049 303 663 1451 1297 412 1393 979